Stop Chasing Followers: How to Transform Your Social Media Into a Revenue Machine in 365 Days | The Nathan Newberry Show 083
Struggling with social media ROI? Learn how Michelle Berman-Mikel’s proven prospecting system turns vanity metrics into revenue streams with just one strategic message per day.
Stop Chasing Followers: How to Transform Your Social Media Into a Revenue Machine in 365 Days
One message a day to the right person can completely transform your business within a year – and Michelle Berman Mikel has the system to prove it.
The Problem with Your Social Media Strategy
Most businesses are caught in an endless cycle of content creation without conversion. They're obsessed with growing followers, perfecting aesthetics, and chasing vanity metrics – all while struggling to generate actual revenue from their social media efforts.
Sound familiar?
In a recent episode of The Nathan Newberry Show, social media prospecting expert Michelle Berman Mikel dropped this truth bomb: "Audience size does not equal revenue. Most professionals don't need more likes; they need more clients."
"The obsession with vanity metrics has led salespeople, real estate agents, and business owners down this path of content creation. But they don't have a conversion strategy for how to turn what they're creating into revenue." – Michelle Berman Mikel
Who is Michelle Berman-Mikel?
Before becoming the social media prospecting queen who speaks on stages worldwide, Michelle was a competitive swimmer who learned the value of discipline and strategic thinking. She swam at the Division I level at Rutgers University and specialized in the mile – the longest event in swimming.
This background became foundational to her business approach. Just as she reverse-engineered the swimming mile by counting down 16 100s, she now helps clients reverse-engineer their social media success by focusing on results first, then building systems to achieve them.
In 2016, Michelle sold her first two Instagram accounts for nearly $90,000, proving her understanding of social media value creation. Today, she helps mortgage professionals, real estate agents, and other entrepreneurs convert their social media presence into consistent revenue.
Social Media Coaching vs. Social Media Prospecting
Timestamp: 07:03
The fundamental problem Michelle addresses is the difference between social media coaching (what most "experts" offer) and social media prospecting (what actually generates revenue).
"Social media coaching helps you look good. Social media prospecting helps you turn the audience you already have into revenue." – Michelle Berman Mikel
This distinction is critical because having 300 engaged followers who trust you can be far more valuable than having 20,000 followers who never convert into paying clients.
The Three-Phase System for Social Media Conversion
Michelle breaks down her approach into three distinct phases:
Phase 1: Fix Your Content Problem with the Four Pillars
Timestamp: 31:51
Most people start with a content problem – they don't know what to post or if what they're posting is effective. Michelle's solution is not a generic content calendar but a custom strategy based on four content pillars unique to each person.
These content pillars should:
Establish credibility through value-adding, educational content
Showcase your personality and interests outside of work
Create relationship opportunities through connection points
Provide a foundation for strategic prospecting
Your content must reflect who you are as a real human being, not just your professional persona. This authenticity becomes critical when you begin prospecting, as it's the first thing potential connections will check.
"If your content doesn't speak to the message you just sent me or isn't aligned with what you just said to me, I'm out." – Michelle Berman Mikel
Phase 2: Prospecting Through Strategic Levers
Timestamp: 25:46
The most powerful concept Michelle introduces is the idea of "levers" – relationships you already have that can help you build relationships with people you don't yet know.
Timestamp: 28:09
A lever is someone who:
Knows you well
Understands what you do
Can speak to your value
Has connections to people you want to reach
The leverage strategy involves:
Identifying your existing strong relationships (levers)
Mapping who they're connected to that you want to reach
Creating personalized outreach that references your mutual connection
Finding additional connection points beyond the professional relationship
"Who do you know that you have a really good relationship with that you can build another relationship with someone that you don't know through them? That's called leverage." – Michelle Berman Mikel
Phase 3: The 365-Day Challenge
Timestamp: 30:27
Michelle's guarantee is simple but powerful: "If you send one message every single day to someone that you do not know through a lever for 365 days, your business will not look the way that it looks right now. That is a 1000% guarantee."
This daily outreach strategy focuses on quality over quantity. Instead of mass-messaging hundreds of people with generic templates, you're crafting one thoughtful, personalized message each day to a strategic connection.
The key elements of an effective outreach message:
Name-drop your mutual connection (leverage)
Reference something personal from their content
Create a non-salesy, authentic call to action
Make them feel like they'd miss out by not responding
Real-World Example: How Michelle Implements Her Own Strategy
Timestamp: 21:59
Michelle shared a concrete example of how she applied her own methodology:
She identified a mortgage lender as a strategic connection she wanted to make
She noticed he was a passionate runner (personal connection point)
She saw he had posted about his running mileage for the year
She took a screenshot of her own Garmin running app
She messaged him with the screenshot saying, "You got me beat by about 5,000 miles"
She name-dropped a mutual connection who appeared in one of his photos
She suggested a call with a low-pressure CTA: "I don't know what could come of it, but at the very worst, it would be a great conversation"
The result? He immediately agreed to a Zoom call, opening the door to potentially working with his team of 50+ loan officers.
This exemplifies relationship-based prospecting versus cold outreach. The initial conversation wasn't about business at all – it was about running, creating a genuine connection before any pitch was made.
Five Actionable Takeaways You Can Implement Today
Audit your content: Look at your last 10 posts. Do they reflect who you are as a person, or are they just generic business content? Make sure your profile shows personality beyond your professional identity.
Identify your levers: List 10 people you have strong relationships with who could introduce you to potential clients or strategic partners.
Map connections: For each lever, identify 3-5 people in their network you'd like to connect with. Look at their social media to find personal connection points.
Create a tracking system: Use Michelle's five-day tracker system to organize who you should be reaching out to each day based on your business goals.
Start the 365-day challenge: Commit to sending one thoughtful, personalized message every day through a lever. Track responses and adjust your approach based on results.
Why This Works: The Psychology Behind Relationship-Based Prospecting
The success of Michelle's approach isn't just anecdotal – it's grounded in psychological principles of influence and relationship building:
Reciprocity: When you show genuine interest in someone's personal passions (like running), they feel compelled to reciprocate that interest.
Social proof: Name-dropping a mutual connection provides instant credibility through association.
Personalization: Taking the time to craft a message specifically for them signals value and respect for their time.
Authenticity: When your outreach matches your content, you create a cohesive and trustworthy personal brand.
"If I send that message and do it right, the person on the receiving side will almost feel guilty not responding to me." – Michelle Berman Mikel
The Grit Factor: Lessons from Competitive Swimming
Timestamp: 11:40
Michelle attributes much of her success to the mental discipline she developed as a competitive swimmer. Her father would ask after every race: "Was that the best that you could do today?"
This question instilled in her a relentless pursuit of excellence and the understanding that results come from consistent daily actions – whether swimming laps or sending strategic messages.
It's this same mentality that drives her approach to social media: the discipline to take daily action, focus on quality over quantity, and maintain a long-term perspective even when results aren't immediate.
Ready to Transform Your Social Media Into a Revenue Machine?
Stop chasing followers and start creating clients. The difference between treating social media as a vanity project versus a revenue-generating asset comes down to strategy and implementation.
Remember Michelle's guarantee: one strategic message a day for 365 days will transform your business. But you don't have to wait a year to see results – clients often begin seeing conversions within weeks of implementing her methodology.
Next Steps to Implement Social Media Prospecting:
Start with your content: Ensure your profile authentically represents who you are beyond your profession.
Identify your strategic levers: Map out relationships you can leverage for introductions.
Create a daily outreach schedule: Commit to the 365-day challenge of one quality message per day.
Track your results: Monitor responses, conversations, and conversions to refine your approach.
Focus on relationships, not transactions: Remember that the goal is to build genuine connections that eventually lead to business, not to make an immediate sale.
Book Your Strategy Call
Ready to implement these strategies but want personalized guidance? Book a FREE strategy call with Nathan Newberry to discuss how to apply these principles to your specific business: https://bit.ly/perform-to-transform
Watch the full interview with Michelle Berman Mikel on The Nathan Newberry Show: https://youtu.be/OB36JFnXrgk
Share this post with an entrepreneur who needs to hear this message about business harmony!
About the Author: Nathan Newberry helps elite business owners implement AI in sales, marketing, systems, and models to build rapidly successful brands. He specializes in helping founders implement Sell By Chat strategy to buy back their time and double their revenue within 6 months using his Elite Sales Model.
